Step 1: Decide on Your Fireplace Personality   

Not all fireplaces are created equal. Some give you that crackle-and-pop wood burning vibe, while others are sleek, modern, and run with the touch of a button.    

When deciding on a type of fireplace, ask yourself:   

💡Do you want the experience of fire, or do you just need a primary heating source?  

💡Do you want low maintenance or are you fine with some upkeep?   

💡Do you want traditional charm or modern efficiency?   

💡What kind of installation process can you commit to — a major renovation or just a simple home upgrade? 

Your answers will guide you straight to the fireplace options you’ll love most, making the shopping process simple and enjoyable.  

Step 2: Learn Your Fireplace Types   

Let’s break down your main fireplace options.   

Step 3: Inserts vs. Built-Ins   

You may have heard the term “fireplace insert” and wondered what it means. Essentially, a fireplace insert is a self-contained firebox designed to fit into your existing fireplace opening.

It’s a smart way to get more efficient heating — some wood burning inserts can be up to 70% more efficient than traditional open fireplaces — update an older hearth and reduce heat loss.   

Step 4: Match the Fireplace to Your Space   

The size of your room, the insulation, and even the layout of your furniture can affect which fireplace works best.

These factors influence not only how much heat you’ll need, but also where the fireplace should be placed for maximum comfort and visual impact.   

✅ Small rooms — Electric or small gas units are great options. They heat efficiently without overpowering the space. 

✅ Large, open-concept areas — Bigger gas or wood burning models ensure warmth reaches across a wider area.   

✅ Apartments or condos — Electric or Ventless gas fireplaces are the best options because they don't require a chimney or venting system. 

Step 5: Think About Style   

A fireplace is as much a design feature as it is a heat source. You’ll want one that blends beautifully with your home decor and draws the eye in, setting the tone for the room.  

Adding a high-quality fireplace not only increases your home’s aesthetic appeal, but it also boosts its overall value. In fact, 77% of buyers are willing to pay more for a home with a fireplace.

The right style, materials, and finish can make it feel like a natural extension of your home’s personality.   

💡 Traditional brick or stone works with rustic or farmhouse styles.   

💡 Sleek glass and metal fit perfectly in modern or industrial designs.   

💡 Mantel surrounds let you decorate seasonally and create a focal point.   

Step 6: Installation Requirements & Safety Considerations 

No matter which style you choose, proper installation is essential for safety and function.   

Wood burning fireplaces require a chimney and must comply with local building codes and clearances to ensure safe operation. Gas fireplaces need professional installation for gas lines. Electric models are the simplest to set up — but even then, always follow the manufacturer’s safety instructions.   

You’ll also want to invest in:   

✅ Carbon monoxide detectors for any fuel-burning fireplace.   

✅ Fire-resistant materials around the fireplace.   

✅ Regular maintenance to keep it safe and efficient.   

Step 7: Maintenance Reality Check   

Here’s the truth: every fireplace has some upkeep. For example, creosote buildup in wood burning fireplaces is a leading cause of chimney fires, contributing to an estimated 25,000 chimney fires in the U.S. each year.   

Doing regular maintenance ensures your fireplace runs safely and efficiently for as long as possible, whether it’s cleaning the chimney, replacing filters, checking gas lines, or inspecting for other safety hazards.   

✅ Wood burning — Chimney cleaning once or twice a year, plus ash removal.   

✅ Gas — Annual inspection to check connections and burner function.   

✅ Electric — Wipe down and dust occasionally; otherwise, zero fuss.   

Think about how much effort you’re willing to put in before making your decision.   

Step 8: Your Project Budget    

Budget plays a big part when narrowing down your fireplace options.  

✅ Electric — most affordable both upfront and long term.  

✅ Gas — more expensive initially but cost-effective for frequent use. For example, Natural Gas fireplaces can save up to 30% on heating costs compared with electric. 

✅ Wood burning — units vary, depending on whether you already have a chimney or need one built.    

Remember to factor in installation, permits, and long-term fuel costs. Sometimes a higher upfront price pays off in efficiency and lower monthly bills.    

Step 9: Your Lifestyle Factor   

Here’s the final and maybe most important step. Your fireplace should suit you. Homeowners who choose a fireplace type that fits their lifestyle report higher satisfaction with their living spaces, with surveys showing over 80% feel it improves comfort and enjoyment.    

If you love the process, tradition, and nostalgic smell, go with a classic wood burning fireplace. If you want instant, mess-free ambiance and energy efficiency, go with gas or electric. The right choice makes your home warmer, cozier, and more you.